Most people choose a grill by looking at the biggest, shiniest model in the store. A better starting point is your own cooking: what you make, how often, for how many people, and where the grill will sit. A grill that fits those answers will get used every weekend, and one that doesn’t ends up covered in the corner of the yard.
This guide covers those questions first, then the features worth paying for, the main fuel types, a few factors people overlook, and what to check before you buy.
Start With How You Actually Cook
What will you cook most? Grilling, smoking and roasting call for different equipment. If you want burgers, steaks and chicken with good char marks, a gas or charcoal grill does the job. If you want slow-cooked brisket or pulled pork, a pellet grill, a smoker or a charcoal grill you can run at low temperatures is a better match. Many weekend cooks do a bit of everything, and for them a versatile mid-sized gas or charcoal grill is usually the sensible choice. Our guide to direct grilling techniques shows how much one grill can do once you know how to use the heat.
How often, and for how many? Burgers for two on the odd Saturday need very little. Cooking several nights a week for a family of six needs a larger cooking surface, sturdier construction and a burner system that recovers heat quickly after you open the lid. As a rough guide, a bigger surface lets you cook everything at once instead of in batches.
What is your budget? Price usually reflects build quality, burner and grate materials, and the number of features. A higher price does not guarantee a grill suits you. A mid-priced grill that matches how you cook is a better buy than an expensive one with features you will never use. Decide on a ceiling before you start browsing, so you compare models inside a realistic range.
How much space do you have? Measure the spot where the grill will stand, including clearance around it. Balcony and small-yard owners should look at compact or portable models, and our ideas for outdoor kitchens on small patios can help you plan the layout. If you want to take a grill camping or tailgating, weight, folding legs and a built-in carry handle matter more than cooking area.
Key Features of a Good BBQ Grill
Build quality. Look at the materials and the frame. Stainless steel, cast iron and thick porcelain-coated grates hold up better than thin painted steel. Pick the grill up by the lid handle and shake the cart gently in the store: wobbling legs and flimsy panels are early signs of a short life.
Temperature control. You want to be able to cook at high and low heat on the same grill. Look for multiple burners with separate controls on a gas grill, or adjustable vents on a charcoal one. That lets you set up a hot side and a cooler side, which is how you cook thick cuts without burning the outside. We walk through that method in our guide to setting up a two-zone fire on a gas grill.
Thermometers. Lid thermometers on many grills read the air near the top, not the heat at the grate, so they can be off. A separate probe for the food is more reliable, and we cover that in choosing a grilling thermometer.
Useful extras. A side burner lets you heat sauce or sides while the meat cooks. A rotisserie attachment suits whole chickens and roasts. Storage shelves keep tools within reach, and a warming rack holds finished food while you cook the rest.
Easy cleaning. Removable grease trays, grates you can lift out and a drip system that sends fat to one catch point all save time after the meal. A grill that is hard to clean tends to get cleaned less often.
Which Fuel Type Fits Your Cooking
The fuel decides how the grill starts, how you control it and how the food tastes, so it deserves a decision of its own.
-
Gas: Starts with a button or knob and heats quickly. It is the easiest choice for weeknight cooking and for people who want little fuss. It gives less smoky flavor than charcoal or wood.
-
Charcoal: Reaches very high temperatures and gives a strong smoky flavor. It takes longer to light and more attention to hold a steady temperature, and you have to dispose of the ash afterwards.
-
Pellet: Burns compressed wood pellets and holds a set temperature automatically, which suits long smokes. It needs electricity to run the controller and feed system, and many models do not sear as hard as gas or charcoal.
-
Electric: Works well where open flames or gas bottles are not allowed, such as some apartments. It offers less smoke flavor and depends on a power outlet.
-
Griddle: A flat steel plate, good for smash burgers, breakfast food and stir-fries. It is not a replacement for a grate if you want char marks and flame. Our comparison of Weber gas grills and Blackstone griddles helps you decide between the two styles.
Factors to Consider Before Buying
Health. Meat cooked until heavily charred contains compounds that health guidance suggests limiting. You can reduce this by cutting away burnt pieces, avoiding flare-ups from dripping fat and not leaving food over very high heat for too long.
Environmental impact. Each fuel has trade-offs: charcoal and wood produce smoke, gas depends on a fossil fuel, and electricity depends on how your local power is generated. The grill’s lifespan matters as well, because one that lasts a decade means fewer replacements than one that rusts out in two seasons.
Safety. Place the grill on a flat, stable surface away from fences, overhanging branches, deck railings and the walls of the house. Keep children and pets back from it, and keep a suitable fire extinguisher or a bucket of sand nearby. For gas grills, check hoses and connections for leaks before the first use each season, and follow the manufacturer’s instructions on gas bottles.
Skill level. Gas grills are the simplest to learn: light them, set the dial and cook. Charcoal and smokers reward practice, because you learn to manage airflow and fuel as you go. If you want to start simple and add skills later, a gas grill with a good heat range gives you room to learn.
Considerations When Purchasing a BBQ Grill
Compare several models. Do not buy the first one that looks right. List the grills that meet your needs for size, fuel, features and budget, then compare them side by side. Our roundups of the best gas grills for 2026 and the best 3 burner gas barbecues for 2026 are a place to start if gas is your pick.
Check the warranty and support. Read what the warranty covers and for how long. Burners, grates and the firebox often have separate terms. Find out whether the manufacturer sells spare parts, because a grill you can repair will outlast one you have to replace.
Read reviews with care. Owner reviews show how a grill performs after months of use, such as whether the paint chips or the igniter fails. Expert reviews test heat distribution and build quality under controlled conditions. Look for problems that several reviewers mention rather than one-off complaints.
Count the upkeep. Every grill needs cleaning, and some need more care than others, especially cast iron and carbon steel, which can rust. Our gas grill maintenance guide lists the routine jobs that keep a grill working well.
Weigh value, not only price. A grill that costs more upfront can be cheaper over the years if it needs fewer repairs and lasts longer. A cheaper grill is a good choice when it covers what you cook and you accept a shorter lifespan. Whichever you choose, buy the one that fits the way you cook on weekends, and you will use it far more often.